I've posted a couple vague entries about making some changes in my life. The truth is, I had been seeing
John again. I had backslid with him for a month in November, and after another month of no contact, he began calling me again. The day after Christmas I spoke to him on the phone for about 10 minutes, so I guess he took that as his cue that it was okay to continue calling me. He called again, catching me by surprise. I had friends in town, and he asked if he could come over. So he did. Then he stayed all night.
We saw each other off and on until last weekend. Each time, he called me(and it wasn't just about sex), and often I declined his invitation to get together, still waffling about seeing him since I knew that ultimately it wasn't good for me. In truth, I hated what we had become: superficial. The only times we had meaningful conversations were on the phone. Don't misunderstand: I'm not blaming him. In fact, it was because of me, though I did find it peculiar that, as communicative as he is, he never tried to engage me in conversation of any depth. When we were together, I could barely even look at him, and I sort of shut down. I was terrified of being close to him again, so I avoided any intellectual or emotional intimacy, but I didn't feel like I was being myself. I also couldn't bring myself to address what was going on between us in the present because I had been so beaten down that I couldn't deal with being rejected by him all over again. (Yes, I get it that these are my issues.)
I knew that I didn't like what I was doing but everything became really clear when I found myself taking a pregnancy test (negative). What the fuck was I doing? How could I have a relationship with somebody who wanted all the benefits of a relationship with me without the commitment of one? I knew I had to put an end to it for myself. If he couldn't deal with his issues that make him a commitment-phobe, then I cannot give myself to him anymore. Because it means something to me. And still does.
I had continued to see him a few more times though sex wasn't part of the equation. Then last weekend he propositioned me, and I turned him down. I told him, "I don't want to be your fuck buddy anymore."
Things got tense. We both felt it. Then he said, "I don't really think of you as fu.... (long pause) Nevermind. It doesn't matter anyway."
I wanted to scream, "If you don't think of me as your girlfriend and you don't think of me as your fuck buddy, then what the hell
do you think?" But I didn't. I didn't say anything at all, and within 30 minutes, he left (he had to go to work).
I couldn't take it anymore. I couldn't
not be me anymore. I had to say the things that had been eating me up inside for months, and I was no longer scared of the rejection.
I called him the next day and invited him out to dinner, but then he cancelled (he got the flu). I waited all week and was on the verge of imploding, then he called on Friday. I told him that I was disappointed when he cancelled because I wanted to talk to him. He said he heard the disappointment in my voice and said he knew what I wanted to talk about (meaning me turning him down).
"Well, yes, but that's only part of it. You see, I hate what we have become, and I can't do this dance with you anymore. I don't feel like myself when I'm around you. I shut down, and that's not me, but it's the only way I can deal with you. I want a relationship that honors the unity of my body, mind and soul, not one that divides part of me against the rest of myself, and you cannot give that to me."
I continued, "I don't know if you quite grasp the amount of pain and hurt I've experienced because of having you in my life, so seeing you now brings up a lot of issues for me. I'm not blaming you. In fact, if anyone is to blame, I am to blame for allowing myself to be involved with you when we obviously want different things. But it became very clear to me that this is not healthy for me. I took a pregnancy test last month, and that was when I knew that I was done. If I became pregnant, I know I couldn't have an abortion. So if it were to happen, even though I don't want children, I would want to know that the person it was with was someone who would not just take responsibility for
his mistake, but someone who could be
with me." (I know John would be a father to a child he sired, but that is entirely different than being a family with me.)
Well, that was the crux of the conversation, It was a little more detailed and elaborate, but you get the idea. He told me that he understood, and that he wouldn't contact me again and would wait to hear from me. He also said he knew that it may be a long time... "Yes, it may be a
really long time, but please respect my decision." He assured me that he would.
I was really emotional and sad at first, but I am fine now. The one thing I have to say is that shutting myself off like I did made it not hurt so bad this time around. What's really sad, though, is that John and I really did have a beautiful relationship. We were best friends, confidants and lovers for a year, and I connected with him in a way that I had never connected with anyone. I wasn't looking for it when it happened, but it did happen. In the end, I think I just thought he was more self aware and more emotionally mature than he actually was... and is. That doesn't make him a bad person - and that's what has been so hard for me all along. I know what kind of person he is. A really good one.
I must confess that part of what has been difficult for me is that I have felt like such a cliche: the girl who wanted more. One of the things that I have been working on is being a little more forgiving of myself. I remind myself that the reason I did get so attached to John was because he opened the door for my feelings of love for him and security in his feelings for me to grow through his words and actions. In fact, I also have to remind myself that I was very clear about my feelings as they developed, and he affirmed them. In the aftermath, I have played a mental game with myself that there is something wrong with wanting a relationship, but now I can say without regret that I
do want love and companionship. Sure, it's too traditional to be post-modern, but that doesn't mean I expect it to be served up with all the trimmings of a fairy tale romance.
I don't believe that another person will complete me. I believe that a good relationship is one where both people are complete individuals who choose to enjoy life together. I don't believe that I have to get married to have a loving, committed, monogamous relationship. I don't believe that I have to make promises of "forever" or that those same promises have to be made to me. But I do believe in love and honesty. I do believe in giving and receiving support. I do believe that I can have a loving, committed, monogamous relationship without entirely merging my life or bank account with someone else's. I do believe that I can still have friends, a life, alone time, and independent thoughts outside of a relationship. I do believe that, while it would sure be nice to have, I just might not ever have it. And I do believe that it's okay if I don't.
When things unraveled between me and John, it was ridiculous. Coincidentally, it was also our first and only argument in the whole time we were involved. The bottom line is that he couldn't put the words behind his actions because he was terrified of them. You may wonder why the words - if indeed they were just words - were so important to me. Well, when a guy in a bar says to him, "Everybody here wants to be you because you've got the prettiest girl in the room" and he replies, "She's just my friend," it bothered me - and his response stunned me. John said that he didn't need anyone to define his relationship, to which I replied that by defining it, then people would know to respect it. I also pointed out that, by saying I was his "friend", he was defining it just as much as if he had said I was his "girlfriend". In fact, he didn't have to say anything to the guy about the nature of our relationship. We were exclusive, we were lovers, we were more than just friends, and it really bugged me that he would reduce it to something less significant than what it was. It made me feel like I was his dirty little secret somehow, even though everybody was in on the secret. That's right - it was evident to most everyone around us that there was something more between us, but as I explained to him, his lack of acknowledgement made me feel disposable. Turns out: I was.
Obviously, it didn't come down to just "the words". It was only indicative of deeper, hidden issues that peppered our relationship. I know that he loves me and cares about me, but after a year, I needed things to be more defined. I wasn't asking for a declaration for the rest of our lives. I was simply asking for him to acknowledge our relationship for what it was.
He told me that of anyone he had ever been intimate with that no one could hold a candle to me and that he didn't want to lose me, but in the end, his fears won out. I told him that I wouldn't have abandoned him. He looked at me sharp and quick and asked, "Why did you say that? Why did you say 'abandon'?" I replied, "It's obvious that you have a fear of commitment, and I believe that fear is rooted in a fear of abandonment. As long as you don't acknowledge our relationship for what it is, then you don't have it to lose." A tear fell from his eye.
A million tears have streamed down mine, but I just don't have any left. At least not for him.
I'll leave you with this: one of my favorite poems by
Linford Detweiler, one of my favorite writers.
I Can't SingSo instead
I have to wrap my arms
Around your head
And pull you to my heart
And squeeze
Just hard enough
To let you know
We could hurt each other
~ the lady love